Round 2 PM's Sent

Tofuboi · Post by **Tofuboi** » Wed Jan 11, 2006 2:21 pm

Bugle wrote:Can someone post a replay?

http://members.westnet.com.au/fragwizar ... ound_2.mpr

kamkor · Post by **kamkor** » Wed Jan 11, 2006 4:16 pm

Tofuboi wrote: But please remember, we didnt have much time to make a decision.

In SDDC2005 R1/R2 we have been judging single rounds offline, spending a lot of time with our judging system/template. In finals, when we had battles we first watched them online, then asked competitors to wait after 2 runs till we have finished watching the replays offline and judging. We were judging by an eye then, if something was not clear I was saying on msn to Stan: A tie, if someone did better then 1 to guy x, 0 to guy y. Same thing Stan was doing, it has worked pretty fair I say. In my opinion, it is better to make drifters wait 2-5 mins rather than making wrong decision.

Tofuboi · Post by **Tofuboi** » Wed Jan 11, 2006 8:01 pm

kamkor wrote:
Tofuboi wrote: But please remember, we didnt have much time to make a decision.
In SDDC2005 R1/R2 we have been judging single rounds offline, spending a lot of time with our judging system/template. In finals, when we had battles we first watched them online, then asked competitors to wait after 2 runs till we have finished watching the replays offline and judging. We were judging by an eye then, if something was not clear I was saying on msn to Stan: A tie, if someone did better then 1 to guy x, 0 to guy y. Same thing Stan was doing, it has worked pretty fair I say. In my opinion, it is better to make drifters wait 2-5 mins rather than making wrong decision.

To be honest, yes I agree with you, it may take longer, but oh well.